| Chapter 1 |
| |
| INTRODUCTION TO THE 'Y' SERVICE
|
The 'Y' - or Wireless Intercept - Services have a history
almost as long as that of radio itself. Early on, it was
realized by intelligence agencies that foreign broadcasts
offered rich pickings from the interception and exploitation of.
This was particularly true of those serving military and
diplomatic communications.
Military Uses
Military exploitation of the communications of hostile,
or potentially hostile, powers really came of age around the
time of the First World War. It was to play an important part in
naval strategy and it was the British Royal Navy that led many
developments. Information that was never divulged or publicly
discussed at the time made it clear that the British naval
success in the Battle of Jutland, and elsewhere, owed much to
Wireless Intercept successes.
By the start of World War II the contribution of the Forces had
become an essential component of the overall intelligence
effort. At the peak of the secret, wartime campaign many
thousands of men and women, from the Royal Navy, the Army and
the Royal Air Force were engaged in duties, which for many years
they could discuss with only those who had shared their secret.
Allied interception work occurred on all fronts, with what is
described as ‘strategic intelligence’ collection concentrated on
a network of major static sites and ‘tactical intelligence’
collection dependent on a variety of mobile and semi-permanent
units.
Public Recognition
The veil of secrecy that had prevailed for several decades
finally began to lift in the 1960s. when in 1967 Winterbottom
was the first to publish a book1 describing the Allied struggle
to break the cyphers produced by the German cipher machine known
as Enigma, His was followed by a number of books all releasing a
little more information on this secret world. Perhaps, most
importantly, the contribution of those who intercepted these l
transmissions, hour after hour, day after day, thus providing
the raw material for code-breaking work, was finally
acknowledged, albeit only lightly.
Due to the sensitivity of the work involved, and it’s
particularly demanding nature, a bond, and a strong sense of
identity and common purpose, grew up amongst 'Y' workers even
though different Corps – even Services, are involved. This
remains a feature of Y Service life today. Servicemen and women
are still engaged in this work though nowadays in considerably
smaller numbers. We are now in the sinister world of overt
electronic warfare supporting military operations, nowadays
nearly always in a peacekeeping or peace support context.
1 Secret and Personal
Kimber 1969 and The Ultra Secret
Weidenfeld & Nicholson 1974.
THE DEVELOPMENT OF SIGNALS INTELLIGENCE
The first use of Wireless communications was in the Boer War
1899 - 1902 and the possibilities of wireless interception were
realized by the military leaders of the time. It was not until
the outbreak of the First world war 1914-1918, however, that
wireless technology had advanced enough for the military to use
it as a really successful tool.
Several separate departments within the War Office had been
given responsibility for different aspects of intelligence
related work, particularly with maps. Centralisation was first
tried out in 1873 when the ‘Intelligence Branch’ was established
and this became the Directorate of Military Intelligence (DMI)
in 1888. In 1904 DMI became part of the Directorate of Military
Operations (DMO); it was made independent in 1915 but then
re-united with DMO in 1922. The two departments were again
separated in 1939.
The various sections of Military Intelligence
(MI) and Military Operations (MO) were kept distinct even when
under a single head. DMO was responsible for outline operational
planning up to the time when an operation Commander was
appointed. It also collected information about British forces
and the armed forces of close allies. DMI was concerned with the
armed forces of enemy countries, distant allies and neutral
countries. It was in close touch with military attaches and
missions abroad and was interested not only in military details
but also in more general historical, topographical and economic
information. Until 1940, when a separate department was
established for the purpose, DMI was also responsible for
censorship. In addition to the departments in London , military
intelligence had staff attached to missions overseas and field
headquarters.
By 1914, radio communications, or wireless telegraphy as these
communications were then known, were used by virtually all of
the world's military and naval forces. The relationship between
frequency or wavelength, power, directivity and range were not
well understood and nor was the possibility and potential of
interception, or deception. The troops and sailors of the
European nations were soon to bear the costs of such negligence.
On 5 August 1914 , the cable ship Telconia lifted the German
overseas telegraph cables from the bed of the North Sea .
Thereafter German diplomatic communications had to go by
wireless, as did signals to the High Seas Fleet and the U boats.
The Authorities appreciated that these could be intercepted and
so they were sent encyphered. Cryptography had been subject to a
lot of study in Britain before the War, particularly at Naval
Intelligence Department (NID), and as a result, specialists at
NID were able to read many of Germany 's diplomatic and
operational signals in a very short time. The knowledge thus
gained gave NID much influence and the work was at times of
major significance, leading indirectly, for example, to the
entry of America into the War following the interception and
deciphering of the notorious Zimmerman telegram.
During the early months of the 1st World War some of the British
wireless sections began picking up signals that they calculated
were originating from the enemy. They realized from the amount
of traffic being intercepted that the Germans were making
considerable use of wireless transmissions for their
communications. It was also discovered that (as with telegraph
line transmissions) they had been enciphered.
Maurice Wright had become a Marconi engineer in England in 1912
(and was later to become Engineer in Chief). In 1914 he was
experimenting with the then new triode vacuum tube in a radio
receiving circuit, working with Captain H. J. Round. The circuit
details are lost, but it was undoubtedly a regenerative
configuration, and it ‘made the interception of long range
communications possible for the first time’ as later reported by
Peter Wright, Maurice's son, (later, a senior official in the
British Counter Intelligence and notorious as the author of ‘Spycatcher’)2.
2 Spy
Catcher, the candid autobiography of a senior intelligence
officer. Peter Wright. Viking Press 1987.
Two days before the outbreak of hostilities in August of 1914,
whilst working at his lab at Marconi at Chelmsford , Wright
realized he was listening to the German Navy. He passed the
intercepts to Captain Reggie Hall of Naval Intelligence. Hall
realized the importance of what he had been given and put Wright
to work building a chain of intercept stations for the
Admiralty. Wright and Round also developed a periodic direction
finding techniques enabling them to track the German fleet,
providing sufficient warning for the British fleet to engage it
on the high seas. In the process, Wright also established a
clandestine intercept station in Norway in 1915.
The intercept stations set up in this effort were to be known as
the "Y" stations. Marconi (merchant navy) receiving stations,
British Post Office stations and an Admiralty "police" station
all provided intercepts to Captain Hall's Room 40 ‘code
breakers’. These stations were soon to be joined by enthusiastic
amateurs. Barrister Russell Clarke and Col. Richard Hippisley
had been logging intercepts of German traffic at their amateur
stations in London and Wales. They reported on their efforts and
as a result they were invited to work for Hall. New intercept
stations went up on the coast. Soon practically all German naval
wireless traffic was finding its way to Room 40.
Intelligence officers were assigned to study the contents of
these intercepted messages and it was realized that it would be
an advantage to locate the enemy wireless stations transmitting
these messages.
Two Marconi technicians were assigned to this task and conducted
experiments on the Wiltshire Downs near to Devizes. They used
modified loop aerials to locate the position of a transmitter,
achieving this by taking bearings from more than two different
locations. By using these loop aerials the location of the
transmitter could be pinpointed with some considerable accuracy.
When the direction-finding results were compared with the
content of the messages, on occasions the transmitters could be
matched with known enemy formations. This enabled intelligence
officers to follow the movements of the formations and the
positions of their headquarters even when the messages could not
be deciphered. This process was later to become known as
traffic
analysis.
The War Office realized the importance of this new area of
intelligence work and created a new department with the director
of military intelligence in charge. The team studied the
resulting intercepts and developed the science of Traffic
Analysis, This involved many areas of expertise such as the
interception of station call signs, tracking operating
frequencies, the study of signals in clear and ciphered text,
making D/F (Direction Finding} fixes, radio finger printing, the
recognition of individual radio operators by the particular
style they used to send Morse code messages.
In a military context, traffic analysis is usually performed by
a Signals Intelligence unit, and can be a valuable source of
information about the intentions and actions of the enemy. For
example when deploying to the field on major exercises, the
scenario could possibly indicate their likely deployment in War.
other indicators and patterns can be very revealing and include:
- Frequent communications — can denote planning
- Rapid, short,
communications — can denote negotiations
- A lack of communication
— can indicate a lack of activity, or completion of a finalized
plan
- Frequent communication to specific stations from a central
station — can highlight the chain of command
- Who talks to whom —
can indicate which stations are 'in charge' and which aren't,
which further implies something about the personnel associated
with each station
- Who talks when — can indicate which stations
are active in connection with events, which implies something
about the information being passed and perhaps something about
the personnel/access of those associated with some stations
- Who
changes from station to station, or medium to medium — can
indicate movement, fear of interception
|
All of this is
invaluable information particularly when studying the enemy’s
“Order of Battle” Although separate, there is a close
relationship between traffic analysis and cryptanalysis
(commonly called code breaking) and addresses are frequently
encrypted requiring assistance in identifying them by call sign
recognition and frequency analysis. Traffic volume can often be
a sign of an addressee's importance, giving hints of pending
objectives or movements to cryptanalysts 3.
During the early days of the War the Royal Navy was having more
success than the Army in the use of wireless communications and
consequently became heavily involved in intercept work. In the
summer of 1914 the Admiralty received reports that the General
Post Office had picked up German signals from their station at
Lowestoft so the Naval intelligence department quickly
authorised an intercept station to be set up at Hunstanton to
monitor this signal traffic. The coast guard hut there was used
to house the equipment and three Radio Amateurs were assigned to
man it. Here a secret tradition began since these were to be the
first of the Voluntary Interceptors or VI’s, whose work was
later to prove so vital in the Second World War.
3 I acknowledge the
unwitting help of Wikipedia in preparing this.
The German high
power long wave station at Norddeich provided fodder for the
code breakers through the Y stations and soon they turned their
attention to higher frequency interception as well. In 1915
these intercepts helped the British to win the naval battle at
Dogger Bank, and were to play vital roles in later naval
engagements.
The direction finding stations working under Round also provided
intercepts to Room 40,The ‘directionals’ tracked U-boats and
Zeppelins as well as naval craft. The Y station intercepts were
to show that the 1915 sinking of the SS Lusitania by a U-Boat
had the approval of the German high command, despite its
strenuous denials. By mobilising public opinion in the USA it
helped entry into the War ultimately leading to victory. The
leading history of the astonishing success of British
intelligence in the First World War concludes: "[the] Y stations
made it all possible."
Perhaps the most famous intercept of all was the infamous 1917
Zimmerman Telegram that would finally bring America into the
war. Briefly, Germany promised Mexico it could have back the
territory it lost in the Mexican American War, if it would join
Germany against the United States . Plucked from the ether by
the British intercept stations and decrypted by Room 40, and
passed on to the USA authorities it enraged the Americans.
Captain "Reggie" Hall4 of Room 40, never known for his modesty,
claimed "Alone I did this.
The British Navy successfully intercepted wireless messages on
the high seas as well. In an outstanding feat of code breaking,
Signal Officer Charles Stuart of the cruiser ‘Glasgow’ was able
to establish that the German cruiser ‘ Dresden ’ would coal at
Juan Fernandez Island (Robinson Crusoe's old second home) off
Chile , by deciphering an intercept from the Nauen Telefunken
station. It is too long to quote here but there is a fascinating
contemporary article on the part that wireless played in naval
history “Wireless Waves in the World’s War (1916),
www.earlyradiohistory.us/1916
4
Admiral Sir William Hall, Director
of Naval Intelligence.
British intelligence also sent Sir Hercules Langrishe
and A.E.W. Mason to destroy the German station in Mexico at
Ixtapalpa in 1918. This Mason did by smashing its Audions,
putting the German agent Herr Jahnke out of business.
There was one other important outcome of the success of British
Army signals units in intercepting German wireless traffic. It
convinced British commanders that wireless was too dangerous a
method of communications to use and the signals units turned
almost exclusively to monitoring and intercept work.
Imperial German army interception of Russian wireless traffic.
The Russian Army used wireless to coordinate its campaigns. It
took virtually no precautions against interception and did not
encode its traffic. In 1914, the Germans won the decisive battle
of Tannenberg against the Russians. The Germans had set up
wireless intercept stations on all fronts and had intercepted
virtually all of the Russian traffic (and it was readable),
through the German radio stations at Thorn, and Koenigsberg in
East Prussia. Incredibly, the intercepts had originally gone to
Hindenberg by motorcycle at the personal initiative of the chief
of the Thorn station, and the whole effort had begun as an
amateur and even sporting endeavour of the operators with time
on their hands.
Tactical intercepts by all belligerent signal services provide
important battlefield intelligence, but radio deception can
become a weapon in its own right. In early September, 1914 the
Russians intercepted a message from German Army Staff
Headquarters from which the Russians inferred a threat from a
new large force, and therefore held back forces of their own in
the upcoming battle. The German Eighth Army staff, however,
anticipating interception, had transmitted in plain text from
its station at Koenigsberg a completely false message. Radio
deception had begun to play its counterpoint to radio
interception right at the commencement of the hostilities The
Germans were to use radio deception again successfully within
weeks.
The Battle of Tannenberg taught the Germans the value of their
intercept efforts. The Russian traffic was read from August 1914
to the close of 1915. One Russian General Officer was later to
term Russia ’s use of plain text and their failure to take
precautions as "unpardonable negligence."
The Austrians had
integrated their intercept service into their Chancellery
cryptographic section at the beginning of the war. They too
regularly intercepted and decrypted Russian traffic throughout
the war.
Amazingly the Germans made the very errors from which they had
profited in the East, in the West. The French even before the
war strove to intercept relevant traffic. At the beginning of
the war in the West, the Germans sought to thrust into France to
defeat the French armies east of Paris. The French had obtained
the whole order of battle, and up to the minute tactical
intelligence by radio intercepts. Just as the Russian thrust
failed in the East for want of radio discipline, so too did the
German thrust in the West turn to defeat at the Battle of the
Marne for exactly the same reasons.
Failure to achieve early decisive victories on either side,
meant that the war degenerated into trench warfare, artillery
battles and gassing, for four horrible years until the arrival
of the tank and the Americans. The superior material and
manpower of the allies, with the entrance of the United States
in April, 1917, finally turned the tide. The United States also
joined the war in the ether. In 1918, the U.S. Army Signal Corps
established its first long range intercept station in Maine, to
listen to Europe, under Lt. Arthur E. Boeder. American "Y"
stations (although that was only the British name for them)
monitored transmissions to German agents in Mexico and South
America. The U.S. Army had used mobile intercept stations as
well as land stations as early as 1916 on the Mexican border,
and well into the 20s. Army Intelligence brought its pre-war
expertise with it in the American Expeditionary Force (AEF) to
France. "Radio intelligence firmly established itself as an Army
intelligence tool in France. In addition to monitoring U.S.
traffic for security violations, Signal Corp intercept stations
located all along the enemy front copied enemy traffic and
pinpointed the location of enemy positions by goniometric radio
direction finding. Intercepted traffic was passed to the radio
intelligence sections at General Headquarters and the two field
armies, where specialists analysed message flow patterns and
attempted to decrypt the messages themselves.
U.S. Army mobile station in France
U.S. Signal Corps Army Receiving Station France 1918
Between the wars
Downsizing was the aftermath of the end of the Great War as it
is of all wars. Intercept services and intelligence functions
shrank. There were, however, untoward "consequences of the
peace" (to use Lord Keynes' phrase). As wireless and radio came
to play a part in future events, so did radio interception. By
the close of the First World War, the allies had turned their
attention not only to the nations of the world, but also to the
subversion by the international communist movement. With the
success of the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia in 1917, all of
the Great Powers felt that they faced a new threat, revolution
from within. The British continued to monitor and decrypt Soviet
transmissions throughout the 1920s.
The Germans themselves valued their military intelligence
section, which was re-instituted on a permanent basis in 1919.
Within Germany itself, the Frei-Corps set up a monitoring
station to listen to communists. This was the time of the ‘Red
Uprising’ and failed Putsch The official German intercept
service concentrated on the international press radio service
until 1925, then gradually turned its attention to diplomatic
transmissions.
In the estimation of one German authority, ‘the
English had the superior radio intercept service between the
wars’, devoted not only to military intelligence but also to
diplomatic traffic. The French had also maintained their
intercept service, as did other nations. By then the Russians
maintained the best discipline and were perhaps the most
effective. The Poles more than held their own. The Italians ran
a lax operation, and other nations had only indifferent success.
In October, 1919 Britain formed the Government Code and Cipher
School (GCCS) by amalgamating Room 40 of the Admiralty and
Military Intelligence. To support its work, they formed the
Royal Corps of Signals ( 28th June 1920 ), which in conjunction
with Admiralty monitoring, would provide the messages for the ‘codebreakers’.
The British Secret Service also took to putting its agents
aboard merchant ships as Marconi wireless operators, when
particular ports of call were of interest. With the threat of
real looming, only the Poles had made any real progress - far
more than the French and the British in understanding Enigma
5. The story of the wartime decryption of the Enigma
traffic is well known and this is no place in which to repeat
it. It may well have won the war in Europe - it certainly
contributed far in excess of its cost. What is not widely known,
perhaps deliberately, is that enemy radio operators' errors gave
away more secrets of the codes and far more often than even the
new electronic computers could break them. This has always been
the case.
5 In 1918 the German
inventor Arthur Scherbius & Richard Ritter founded a Company
that would eventually lead to the invention of the most fearsome
system of encryption in history - at least until the 1950's
Soviet subversion in
Britain and Ireland provided GCCS its first important work, with
civil unrest widely feared.
The London ‘Times’ ran a story that
wireless intercepts showed the Soviets funding subversive
activity in August of 1920. Despite a treaty prohibiting
domestic subversion, the Soviets kept it up but, by then they
were being monitored in detail by the wireless intercept
stations and decrypted at GCCS. Various diplomatic initiatives
attenuated the subversion for a while but also brought about the
use of one-time encoding pads, very difficult, if not impossible
to decrypt.
In 1930 an intercept station detected a circuit
between Moscow and a suburb of London and it was not until the
Spanish Civil War in 1936 that the British turned away from
their focus on the Soviets. It has since been speculated that
the circuit between Moscow and London ( fully decrypted by
GCCS), was left in place in order to monitor the success of Comintern subversion at Cambridge and Oxford, and which would
lead to the Philby affair many years later. During the Thirties
the Russians had dedicated themselves to the overthrow of the
United Kingdom Government and the British were aware of this
from intercepts and seized documents; priority, however, had to
be given to dealing with the Nazis, who had even more immediate
plans, as became clear in 1936, 1938 and 1939.
The British had maintained a "Y" committee since 1925 to
coordinate the work of intercepting radio signals. The Army had
its chain of stations throughout the Empire, as did the Navy.
The Post Office and the Air Ministry ran the domestic stations.
Those listening heard and logged the traffic, but understanding
it was another matter.
American success had borne fruit at the 1921 Washington Peace
Conference. Army Military Intelligence (MI-8) code breakers
decrypted the Japanese diplomatic code, giving the Americans a
considerable advantage whilst negotiating. The Army, on a
tactical level, also engaged in monitoring and direction
finding, as is illustrated by the 1940 set pictured operating in
Hawaii.
The U.S. Navy also focused on the Japanese (as to some extent
had the British too). In 1927 (later Admiral) Ellis Zacharias
set up a monitoring station in Shanghai , the first of a chain
across the Pacific. Zacharias set up his receivers on the fourth
floor of the American Consulate. By 1940 the chain of stations
included the Aleutians Islands, the Philippines at Corregidor,
Samoa, Guam and Hawaii and Bainbridge Island, WA, Winter Harbor,
ME, Jupiter, FL and Chelten on Oahu.
The US Army, despite the closing of the Black Chamber, operated the
Signal Intelligence Service. The brilliant William Friedman ran
the small group, which ultimately broke the Japanese Purple
Code, providing the MAGIC decrypts that possibly won the war in
the Pacific. It is said that Friedman broke that code without
any captured machines or codebooks (unlike the British success
with the Enigma codes). Friedman's was an unequalled feat of
mind that nearly cost him his life.
The Americans and British traded intelligence information on the
Japanese. The British in this period, the thirties, had four
intercept stations in Australia, plus a Dutch station removed
from Indonesia . It was the US intercept station at Bainbridge
that took the communication from Tokyo to the Japanese
Ambassador that instructed him to break off negotiations at 1 PM
Washington time, or just after dawn in Hawaii on December 7,
1941.prior to the attack on Pearl Harbour.
SIGNALS INTELLIGENCE
After the outbreak of the Second World War, MI 8 was formed and
was given the responsibility for Signals Intelligence (SigInt),
which included the Y Services. By then the Y Services consisted
of several different departments; the RAF, Army, Navy,
Metropolitan Police, Post Office and the Foreign Office. Each
service was used to listen to the coded signals of their
opposite numbers within the enemy's forces.
Also, in 1939, the Government issued the new defence
regulations, which altered the licensing conditions under which
the Radio Amateurs in Great Britain could operate. These
regulations restricted the use of Amateur Radio Transmitters
except with the direct permission of the government. This was
done to combat the threat of enemy agents operating transmitters
from within the British Isles.
The Voluntary Interceptors - RSS
In order to monitor and police this threat MI5 created a new
organisation called the Radio Security Service (RSS) which
operated as part of the Y Service. This new department was given
the cover designation of MI8c and was headed by Major Worlledge
whose brief it was to intercept, locate and close down any
illicit wireless stations operated by enemy agents or by other
persons not licensed to do so under the new ‘Defence Regulations
of 1939’.
Early in 1940, from the temporary HQ set up in
Wormwood Scrubs prison with virtually no staff, no receiving
stations and no skilled radio operators, Major Worlledge in MI8c
set Lord Sandhurst the task of finding him the skilled wireless
operators that he needed. Lord Sandhurst approached the Radio
Society of Great Britain (RSGB) for assistance. Founded in 1913
the R.S.G.B. still looks after and furthers the interests of
Britain 's Radio Amateurs.
On their recommendations a secret army of voluntary operators
was slowly recruited from the RAF's Civilian Wireless Reserve
and the country's radio amateurs. These people became known as
the Voluntary Interceptors or VIs and by using equipment set up
in their homes they were initially given the job of listening
out for traffic flowing between the Abwehr (German Intelligence)
base stations and their agents in the field known as "foxes".
The VIs had to sort out the weaker signals transmitted by the
foxes from all the other radio traffic which had much stronger
signals, but this was easy for the VIs. Being radio amateurs
they were used to seeking out weak signals and soon became
skilled in this task. Eventually enough VIs had been recruited
to cover a 24hr service and those who could send in more than 48
logs a month were excused from other onerous civilian duties
such as fire-watching and Air Raid Patrol work.
As a cover it was decided to set up a special branch of the
Royal Observer Corps into which the VIs were enlisted and issued
with uniforms. After a few months the RSS had out grown its
temporary headquarters and moved to Arkley View in Middlesex.
Soon after this move it was realised that there were no enemy
agents operating from in Great Britain and according to the
traffic analysts at Arkley all of the intercepts then being
received were from enemy nets operating solely on the continent.
The task of the VIs was now complete, but instead of disbanding
them, they were now diverted to monitoring the traffic on the
continent. In a relatively short time Lord Sandhurst had turned
his army of radio amateurs into a highly professional unit
dedicated to their work. The VIs had spent many hours listening
on their receivers, never able to tell their families what they
were doing.
By late 1940 the growth in the number of VIs was causing
difficulties for the ‘Services’, who were finding it hard to
recruit enough experienced operators to man their own Y
stations. In late 1940 the Prime Minister asked Lord Hankey to
investigate this shortfall. On his recommendations a substantial
number of VIs were transferred into the military services to man
their Y stations. This move was bitterly resented by Major
Worlledge, but even so there were still some 1500 voluntary
Interceptors working for the RSS by the end of the war.
Experimental Wireless Assistants
In late 1940 when these radio amateurs were sent to be part of
the military Y Services they were enlisted as Civilian
Operators. They were given the title Experimental Wireless
Assistants (EWA's). The EWA's were now very skilled wireless
operators and were joined by male staff from the Post Office and
Merchant Navy. This helped to fill some of the shortfall in
wireless operators that were needed to operate the expanding
amount of wireless receivers at Beaumanor Park and other Y
Stations around the country.
Special Wireless Operators
This expansion was due to the increasing enemy wireless
communications traffic as the Axis forces invaded more of Europe
. The Deputy Director of Military Intelligence decided that the
solution of the problem of the shortage of skilled operators lay
in training military people to fill this role and a decision was
made to train women of the ATS, WRENS and WAAF to perform the
operating tasks. For the first time these new military personnel
would be women and given the title ‘Special Wireless Operators’.
Beaumanor Army Y Station
In 1941 the Fort Bridgeworks army barracks near Chatham were
bombed and some of the women stationed there on Military work
lost their lives, so a decision was made to move the Army Y
station. The move was to RAF Chicksands in Bedfordshire (now
well-known as being the current ‘Home’ of the Intelligence
Corps), and was hailed as "the promised land" to the personnel
of the newly named Special Wireless Group (SYG). Their stay,
though, at Chicksands was both short and unhappy. Shortly after
this a second move to the "promised land" took place. This time
it was to be their home until the end of the war. Beaumanor Hall
near Quorn in Leicestershire was the location prepared for the
newly named (again) War Office Y Group (WOYG) and would become
the Head Quarters hence WOYG HQ. The RAF personnel stationed at
Beaumanor were then moved to Chicksands to combine with the
other RAF staff at the base and were given the title ‘Special Y
Service’. This was to be their home until the end of the war.
1942 -1946
At Beaumanor in the Second World War the intercept programme was
focused on the interception of the Wehrmacht's Enigma coded
wireless traffic and this work was largely conducted by the Army
personnel stationed there. You should not forget however the
work carried out in H Hut by the Civilian EWA's of whom many
were originally Radio Amateurs.
During the war some 8000 men and women from the RAF, Army, Royal
Navy, Post Office, Metropolitan Police and the Foreign Office
were engaged in duties at the many Y stations located in this
country and around the world. Their daily task was to intercept
enemy radio communications and to provide the raw material for
the code breakers at Bletchley Park.
Many Y Stations were located abroad and often consisted of field
and mobile units whose work must not be overlooked, as this
played just as vital a role as that carried out by the fixed
stations located here in the United Kingdom. Many of them were
even more at risk as they operated in isolation at locations
very close to the enemy lines and with very limited protection.
Many of these courageous people lost their lives or were
captured by the enemy.
The Y Service was the "ears" of Bletchley Park and without this
vital service the Government Codes and Cipher School would not
have been able to function. This fact is invariably understated
or overlooked in the intrigue surrounding the secret code
breaking activities carried out by G.C&C.S. during world war
two. It is never given the recognition it is due in any of the
vast amount of literature that has since flooded out and for
which the appetite of the Public is seemingly insatiable It is
perhaps worth quoting from David Kahn’s classic book “Seizing
the Enigma” to illustrate the point:-
“Welchman (a Cambridge
mathematician who had been recruited to Bletchley at the
outbreak of war) quickly perceived that the traffic patterns
reflected the organization of the German army “The callsigns
came alive”, he said, “as representing elements of those forces
whose commanders at various echelons would have to send messages
to each other. The use of different keys … suggested different
command structures.”
He thought he was independently inventing a
form of intelligence called traffic analysis” I do not think any
comment is required.
Not all was perfect as far as inter – Service relationships were
concerned. It is interesting to read Aileen Clayton’s “The Enemy
is Listening” 6 .
For example, this is how she describes the relationship between
the services.
“In the desert, there was a noticeable improvement in the
liaison between the RAF and the Eighth Army … and this
co-operation was reflected in the attitude of the two Y Services
to each other”.
When writing on the fiasco in Crete she writes:
“What is so regrettable is that neither the Army nor the Navy
fully appreciated the air situation. They were sceptical of the
Enigma warnings, and blamed the RAF for letting them down, which
led, not for the first time, to ill-feeling between the Services
“.
The ill-feeling between the Army and the RAF had reached such a
pitch after the hurried retreat from the Desert in 1942 that
Tedder actually warned that ‘he would court-martial any RAF
personnel who referred to the Army as ‘pongos’ or ‘The
Retreatists’ (With prejudice Cassell 1966). Not everything was
harmony between the various Y Services, by a long way.
6
The Enemy is Listening - the story
of the Y Service, Crecy Publishing, Manchester, 1993. It is an
excellent history ( as far as one can tell ) of the Royal Air
Force efforts, however the Army contribution is barely mentioned
and the Naval contribution little more. It is extremely
partisan, as a result.
1945 -1970
The Y Service was not disbanded at the end of the war, but many
changes took place to enable it to emerge reborn again.
Beaumanor became a GCHQ controlled, civilian operated, Y
Station, and the technology and the people formed an evolving
timeline, through to 1970 when Beaumanor received it's last
message and the new owners took over.
This is not the whole story nor is it the end and more will be
added. Suffice it to say that we, at Langeleben, played a
significant part in the story - way out of proportion to our
size.
I hope those who have unwittingly
supplied so much of this information, invariably anonymously,
through several internet sites will forgive me for having helped
myself so freely to their work. ed
THE NATIONAL SERVICEMAN
The first National Service Acts were passed during the Second
World War. However, following the war, conscription was extended
as peacetime National Service. This was due in part to an
unstable international situation, as well as to Britain 's
responsibilities in the commonwealth and empire. The 1948
National Service Act, effective from 1 January 1949 , fixed the
period of National Service to eighteen months with 4 years in
the reserves. In 1950, the Korean War led to a further amendment
increasing the period of service to two years, with three and a
half years in the reserves. Men in Northern Ireland were
excluded from the National Service under the Act.
Not all were to serve in the Forces. Bevin (or Bevan) Boys were
young men who worked "down the pit" instead of serving in the
armed forces as coal mining was an important "reserved
occupation". The Bevin Boy scheme was set up by Ernest Bevin,
the wartime Minister of Labour ending in 1951, "National
Service" or the 'call-up' finally came to a halt on 31 December
1960 and the very last National servicemen left the Army in
1963.
The last National Serviceman was. Private Fred Turner (23819209)
Army Catering Corps at the time attached to the 13/18 Hussars.
He was discharged on 7 May1963 and had the latest number issued
to a National Serviceman. However, Lieutenant Richard Vaughan,
Royal Army Pay Corps, left his unit in Germany on 4 May 1963 but
because he had to travel back to England was not officially
discharged until13 May1963.
In 1951 the Army more than the RAF and Navy found itself in an
extraordinary position. There were still a considerable number
of Regular soldiers who had either enlisted during the War or
who, having initially been conscripted, had signed up to become
Regulars and National Servicemen who, on the whole, resented
every minute of the time that they had to spend serving their
Country. This resentment was fuelled by the fact that the
‘regular’ was paid considerably more than the National
Serviceman for doing the same work and had the somewhat dubious
pleasure of being able to choose in which Service, Regiment or
Corps he wished to serve - within reason. There was only pay
parity in the last 6 months of National Service.
Amongst the Regulars there were also what were originally called ‘Boy
Soldiers’ who had, for numerous reasons enlisted in the Army at
what seemed, to the National Servicemen a very young age and
were very experienced in all things ‘military’, This all laid
the ground for potential tensions and it is surprising in
retrospect that it did not give rise to more problems than
actually arose.
There was one other problem for the National Service ‘Criminal’.
Any time ‘served’ in any of the infamous
military prisons was deemed not to count and for some the two
years became four.
To the National Serviceman the concept of
actually volunteering to serve was almost incomprehensible and
to have signed up for ’22 years without the option’ was, to
them, verging on madness. Virtually from the first day in the
Army the NS recruit counted what was known as ‘Days to do’.
These went down daily from 730 to the magic ‘demob day’. On
meeting up with a squaddie who was not known to you one of the
first questions asked was usually “how many have you got to do?”
If it was more than you one had a feeling – even if it was only
one day – of great superiority, The daily decreasing numbers
were often marked inside one’s locker. What effect this had on
the average ‘regular’ is not known but the minimum that they
would ’do’ would be 1095 a truly daunting figure.
Perhaps at
this point it is worth saying that the Navy enlisted far fewer
NS personnel than the other two Services and it was perceived,
whether based on fact or not that, overall, the brighter
conscripts chose or were chosen for the Royal Air Force. Another
aspect of NS that rankled with young men was that it was limited
to men even though the women’s services existed.
Service started
at the age of18 but it was possible to get deferment to,26 for
most of its life. This enabled you to go to University or
College before doing national service and to obtain a Doctorate
whether it were in Medicine or philosophy. It also applied to
those taking apprenticeships or articles, such as Solicitors or
accountants. This created what was quite a bizarre cocktail. You
could find in an intake an ex-Boy soldier who was fully trained
both as a soldier and a craftsman aged 17; someone aged 17 or
more who had signed up as a Regular for 3 years with the option
to extend his service in 3 year stints and someone who it was
seen as ‘signing his life away for the next 22 years’ with the
relevant financial reward for doing so. The age range went from
17 via 18 as a National Serviceman up to 26. Even more complex
was the fact that there were even those who had re-enlisted not
enjoying life in the ’outside world’.
Just to add to the
confusion there were those who had barely bothered with any
education, those who were coming straight from school and having
to mix equally with those who were able to put those magic
letters ‘PhD’ after their name, solicitors and accountants. They
came from what were still then, the extensive slums of London,
Liverpool and Glasgow through to the hallowed halls of Oxford
and Cambridge. It should not be forgotten that in those days
there were very few University ’places’ and Graduates were held
in some awe. Many of the recruits from these poorer areas also
suffered from malnutrition. Finally there were still many
serving in the Forces who had fought or served during the Second
World War. A heady cocktail and one that one had thought would
be an inevitable route to disaster on a massive scale. But
somehow it was not!
The Korean crisis had ended by 1953 and
there was no fear of it erupting again but the Cold War in
Europe was beginning to build up a nice head of steam. Although
there was no major conflict there were little fire-fights going
on all over the world. There was Cyprus and ‘Enosis’, the
Communist uprising in Malaya; Kenya and Mau Mau; Aden and, of
course, in 1956 the infamous Suez adventure which was to bring
down a Prime Minister and have Britain hang its head in shame.
It was also one of the few occasions until the Iraq affair when
Reservists were to be called back into service – many of them
National Servicemen
In 1960 the last National serviceman
started serving his time and there was much relief all round.
There was little for them to do. The country needed the labour
force and the Military wanted to become a Professional
organisation and so it was a popular decision There are still
many calling for its re-introduction with many seeing it as the
universal panacea to Britain’s ills as if they had never existed
before1960. No doubt in many ways in the current climate the
Government if not the Military would certainly welcome an
increase in numbers. Social observers would certainly welcome
the removal of the bulk of the 18 to 20’s males if only to
monitor the outcome.
One aspect of N.S. which is frequently
overlooked is ‘Conscientious Objection’. Refusal to serve could
be based on either religious or moral grounds. Despite
‘coaching’ by such organisations as the Peace Pledge Union (PPU)
and the Quaker movement it was not an easy option appearing
before the Tribunal where such questions as “what would you do
if you saw a Russian raping your sister/Mother/girl friend?” It
was not an easy being vilified by all sides.
LANGELEBEN - IN THE BEGINNING - 1951
The first extract from John Richardson’s Story of Langeleben
On the far
side of the world the Korean War was still raging, while in the
United Kingdom the Festival of Britain was about to open its
gates to thousands of visitors. On the mainland of Europe NATO
Forces faced the Soviet Union 's massive army across the inter-zonal
border in a desolate and divided Germany . As part of the
British Army of the Rhine (BAOR), Number 1 Wireless Regiment,
based at Münster Westphalia, kept an electronic watch on the
group of Soviet Occupation Forces Germany, which was poised to
cross the border from its garrisons in the Soviet Zone of
Occupation.
Opposing BAOR on the North German Plain was the crack 3 Shock
Army, with its Headquarters in Magdeburg, while to the north of
Magdeburg was located one of the largest training areas in
Eastern Germany, the Letzlinger Heide, which before 1945 had
linked up with the Lüneburg Heide to form Germany's largest
troop training area. As its nearest point lay within fifteen
miles of the border, the fear was of a surprise attack which
could be launched against the West following on from large-scale
Soviet manoeuvres in the Heide.
1 Wireless Regiment's nearest asset was 101 Wireless Troop,
stationed in Hildesheim south of Hannover, but it was felt that
this was too distant to keep a close watch on activities across
the inter zonal border. From their base at Hildesheim 101
Wireless Troop carried out a recce to find a more forward
location.
LANGELEBEN was the result.
WELCOME TO LANGELEBEN
CLICK TO ENLARGE
LANGELEBEN is a hamlet situated around nine hundred feet up on
the Elm feature, midway between Braunschweig and Helmstedt, some
ten miles from the inter-zone border. The site had been occupied
by the RAF during the Berlin Airlift (1948-9), and Taff W...
remembers that they had left a steel shed with a power source at
the top left hand corner. This was not the highest point on the
feature, the highest point had been occupied by an American unit
(today the site of the British Forces Broadcasting Service
Drachenberg radio transmitter).
CLICK TO ENLARGE
The honour of possessing the
first semi-permanent accommodation went to the gentlemen of the
guardroom, who were built a wooden hut. A word about these
characters, who belonged to the Mixed Service Organization
(MSO), and were mainly Yugoslav, speaking little German and even
less English. Syd G....... thought that they were saving up to
go to the
USA
.
Those who got to know them from sharing guard duties can confirm
that they were real eccentrics. Occasionally they would turn up
for duty in a somewhat 'tired and emotional' state which on one
occasion required the assistance of the local police to escort
one of them home.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
By and large, they were grand chaps, the like of whom we will
not see again. Syd G....... remembered that as an experiment,
the MSOs were replaced by a county Regiment . This however only
lasted a few weeks, and was abandoned after 'disturbances' in
Königslutter. The last of this happy band, Stefan W...........
retired in 1984.
In 1955 the first wooden huts were erected for living
accommodation, cookhouse, etc. Operations were carried out from
a complex formed from wagons backed together; later a
semi-permanent covering of corrugated iron was added.
Accommodation was very basic. Washing facilities came in the
form of brown tin bowls, and the single bath stood on a concrete
floor. As drains were non-existent, the plug was pulled and the
water simply ran over the floor to find its own level. The tin
bowls were also emptied onto the floor. An alternative was to
get into Königslutter and take a bath for 50pf.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Toilet facilities were definitely not for the squeamish,
consisting of tin drums , which were emptied once a week by the
Königslutter refuse operatives. After about three days use, one
had to be desperate to use them. The same opinion seems to be
true of the cookhouse. Poor facilities, poor food for over 100
Officers and Men five times a day prepared by 3 cooks was a
recipe for disaster. Fortunately the 'Waldwirtschaft' did
excellent meals. The Officers fared somewhat better - being
accommodated in the 'Waldwirtschaft', although joining the
Senior NCOs for meals in camp. Entertainment was a problem, with
no bus service to Königslutter, a 'recreational' service was
instituted, which entailed a truck driving the pleasure seekers
into town in the early evening and then doing the rounds of the
local hostelries late at night. The older inhabitants of
Königslutter remember the late night antics with obvious
affection, sometimes helping incapable drunks back onto the
lorry.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
One less expensive way of letting off steam was to indulge in
sports. In 1957 the camp team took over the fixtures of the
Königslutter third team so that the team could be sure of
regular fixtures. Watch commitments meant that the same team was
rarely fielded twice. The most famous member of this side in the
fifties was of course 'Yorkie' B...., later of England World Cup
1966 fame, but here as Signalman Driver B....., Bob R.....
remembers that during one of the games, the opposition's manager
spent most of the game behind Yorkie's goal, trying to sign him
up! Apparently 'Yorkie' got a bit fed up with his inactivity in
many games, so was occasionally played as centre forward to let
the other 'keeper' Ray B...... have a game. Through the years
Langy soldiers continued to play in Königslutter. Bill H...,
John S....., and Foxy F..... all played for the now-defunct FC
during the seventies. Paul T.... was even good enough to be
considered for the Lower Saxony Amateur side, although exercise
commitments prevented him turning out.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
For a night out in Königslutter, according to Derek S......, The
'Deutsches Haus' was favourite, where beer cost one Deutschmark,
or if they were hard up, Schumanns' where beer was 50 pfennings.
In 1955 the favourite music on the Juke Box was 'Rock around the
clock' and ' Yellow rose of Texas '. The beer was usually 'Gala
Pils' which remained a favourite through the years until the
brewery disappeared in a take-over by Feldschlösschen in the
early 1970s.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
During the Hungarian Uprising in 1956, the unit was on full
alert. One Saturday night instructions were received to call all
personnel back to camp. Syd G......., the pay clerk, had the
unenviable task of going round town to round everyone up!
Eventually this was achieved, and the unit made ready to
evacuate, with the cooks and pay clerk defending the road
against possible attack from Russian tanks! Fortunately the
stand-down was ordered shortly afterwards. Facilities on camp
slowly improved. After the first admin inspection, a PRI bar and
juke box was provided, and an additional block with baths and
showers was built. Four times a week a film was shown.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Pay was doled out at a pay parade every two weeks, a mixture of
BAFSVs (British Armed Forces Special Vouchers - for use in NAAFI
canteens only) and Deutschmarks. The exchange rate was 12 Marks
to the pound. BAFSVs were retained in BAOR until the early
1960s, but continued to be used in Berlin until 1 January 1977 .
Syd G....... remembers a pay parade where a BAFSV note was
pinned to the table - each soldier counted his pay including the
pinned down note and reported 'Pay and Pay Book correct, Sir'.
The money collected was given to Sid H....., who as duty driver
had been made a scapegoat for a cracked engine on a frozen
vehicle, and fined £130.
CLICK TO ENLARGE
Christmas was obviously a special time in LANGELEBEN. One day,
shortly before the festivities, the OC happened to look out of
his window in time to see a horse-drawn brewer's dray, loaded to
overflowing with barrels and crates, struggling up the hill into
camp. The office clerk broke the news to him, that this was the
troops' Christmas order! After recovering from shock, the OC
placed the booty under lock and key until Christmas Eve. Each
room was decorated for the festive season, and a bottle of gin
awarded to the best. The drayman was Hans K....... of
Königslutter, who remembers having to deliver each hut with a
barrel of beer, which he then proceeded to tap, and was of
course invited to share a drink with the troops. This was
repeated in each hut, until the time came for the horse to take
him home! Incidentally, Hans did sterling work for Langeleben
for many years, eventually becoming the Wolters Brewery
representative until the late 1980s, and his daughter married
Signalman Dave J.... Travel to Langy has never been easy. In the
days before air trooping, the route from UK was via troopship
from Harwich to the Hook, and then the British Military Train to
Berlin . The RTO on the train was always puzzled when the train
stopped off at the Königslutter sidings, where he had to open a
door and let two or three bods off, who walked across the tracks
to climb over the station wall and onto a waiting truck (if they
were lucky, as the truck was more than likely parked outside a
pub!).
In 1957 101 Wireless Troop was raised to Squadron status and
became No. 2 Squadron, 1 Wireless Regiment, whose RHQ was now in
Birgelen. The Regiment shortly became 13th Signal Regiment
(Radio).
|
The following is an extract from the American ASA website, well
worth a ‘visit’
www.nasaa-home.org/asa/slagle/konis.html
Königslutter
1954 Summer Encampment
(aka Sollingen, Schoningen, 31Fox)
|
May 1954 to Nov 1954
I was assigned to 331st Communications Reconnaissance Company
(C.R. Co.) 5th Corp located at Giessen. Upon arriving in Giessen,
I found out that the 331st C.R. Co. was on detached service near
Königslutter in the British Zone of Germany. After loading my
gear in the back of a truck, and getting into truck for a three
to four hour ride to Sollingen, near Helmstedt, I finally
arrived at my assigned company and destination known as "31
Fox" and which was to be my home until mid November 1954.
"31 Fox" was a communications intelligence intercept site, that
is an electronic monitoring location to intercept, copy and
decode the Communist Army Military messages. The company was
scattered about northern Germany; HQ was at Giessen, "31 Fox"
was the main operations monitoring site near Sollingen, and 3
out post DF stations ; 31 Able was at Lubeck, Bahrdorf was Det
1, located near Velpke, I don't recall the site designator for
Wesendorf located near Gifhorn. There may have been more
outstation sites that I am unaware of being in use at this time.
The 331st C.R. Co. was spread out over a distance from Giessen,
just north of Frankfurt to Lubeck. I believe that Major
Sutherland was C.O .at that time. Being a radio repairman, I had
the opportunity to travel to the different out stations. At "31
Fox" we lived in squad tents, and worked in van trucks.
"31 Fox" was located in the Elm Mountains, on top of a hardwood
ridge, which provided natural camouflage for a "spy" type of
operations. The only open area was along border road between the
base of a 187 meter high radio relay tower, that relayed
messages across the then Russian Zone into Berlin about 110
miles to our east. This is was where our tent row was located;
all of the operations areas were hidden in the woods away from
prying eyes.
In the morning you would awaken and hear the Cuckoo birds, look
out to an open field and see roebucks feeding. It rained 27 days
out of 31 days in July 1955 and, as you would guess, we had mud,
mud and more mud. (Just like in the movies).

We had a "Beer Tent" where we could go and have a beer in the
evening. There was a British Signal detachment at Kinderheim
about a mile away, doing the same job we were doing, they would
come over at night and bend a few elbows with us. I got into
their operations area and was able to see the old communications
equipment that they were using. Strictly ham gear pre WW II
vintage, we were using Hammarland SP600's and Collins gear (pre
R390 ) state of the art in 1954. I wonder what ever happened to
two of the "Brits", Derrick Wakefield and Allen Spurgeon; I
visited with them at South Ruislip about 20 miles out side of
London in the summer of 1955.
In late August or early September 1954 whilst we were at 31 Fox
(Sollingen), we had a scheduled company party, for all personal.
Everyone was there except the trick on duty; they rented a hall
in Königslutter for the party. We had all kind of foods and beer
to consume, about two hours into the party, when every one was
starting to get "feeling good"; we had a "red alert" the Eastern
Bloc nations went on manoeuvres. The Soviet navy was moving south
along the coast of Norway, the Red Army tanks were moving
towards the border, and their air force were joining in the
games. We were loaded on to vehicles and moved back to 31 fox as
quickly as possible. They found four 50's for our "protection"
(I don't think anyone saw anything heavier than a 30 calibre in
basic and even knew how to load or fire a 50 calibre), we went
to work as soon as we got back. Placing all the racks of
communication equipment on mattress on the floor of the vans,
cutting all runs of coax and ground wires and etc. with fire
axes at each vehicle so we would be able to clear out, to where
I don't know. It took us about a week to repair all the damage
that we did with the fire axes. The only casualty we had that
night was one sprained ankle from a guy jumping out of the back
of a 2 1/2 ton truck.

"31 Fox" broke camp and went back to Giessen for the winter, we
were stationed at the Quarter Master Depot Kasserne.
Dean Slagle
Dear Dean
You mentioned a red alert in '54. I remember it well. The entire
company was at the Deutsches Haus, which was pretty much run by
my future mother-in-law. Another fellow and I (I forget his
name, but was later my best man) were out with a couple of
Königslutter's finest. He had torn his pants and we had to go
back up the hill for a change. As we were going up the hill, all
of our motor pool was coming down, and fast.
When I pulled up, someone in full field, with rifle, told me to
get those girls back to town and get back at once. I remember
taking the junk out of my backpack and putting the real thing
back in. We were gathered inside the second inner wire (where I
worked) and Capt? (Sutherland) Told us there were strange
Russian ship manoeuvres in the North Sea, and we were on full
alert. He mentioned the company's entire armament was nine .50
cal machine guns. He asked if anybody knew anything about them.
It didn't take me long to realize no one knew anything. I told
him I did (I had just come out of ROTC at Lehigh. I knew the .30
& .50 well, as well as the 1911, M1 carbine and rifle, and BAR.
Three of those I had to disassemble and reassemble blindfolded)
He told me to choose men and set up emplacements on the eastern
side of the camp. I asked him what we should do in case tanks or
planes come. He said shoot! The .50s may have made some dents in
our armour in WWII, but not Russian. I helped carry a lot of that
stuff to the perimeter. It was damn heavy, especially the
tripods. I couldn't quite remember the headspace, 7 or 9 clicks,
but I wasn't sure. I got all nine set up with two men each. I
remember people coming behind us asking for the password. We
were scared, especially of tanks which we knew well weren't that
far away. Finally, it grew light. I looked around and everyone
had gone to bed, so we did too. It just fizzled out. We didn't
get much help putting those guns away either. Maybe I should sue
the government for my two hernia operations.
I remember when we dropped off the girls, I was thinking to
myself we would never see them or the USA again. What was the
captain's name? I will tell you more of him at a later date.
Years later I revisited our site several times. I used to run,
and my son and I ran all over the hill. There is no evidence of
anything being there. The antenna is still there. My wife's
sister's father-in-law climbed that thing once to take photos.
More guts than I have. Does anyone know Phil Petit or Van Peter
Phillips? Phillips left the company in '53, was from Oakland and
had gone to Monterey. When we were tested in Fort Devens, my
language learning abilities were as good as my code learning.
I'll never forget the corporal sitting there on the porch
assigning mos's. He said "code school". I begged him for
Monterey, I pointed out my scores and told him I had already had
five years of French. Naturally, I went to code school.
Jim Tobias
End of chapter 1
|
| |
| |
|
|